×
〈 〉

20 Overrated Video Game Protagonists


20 Overrated Video Game Protagonists


Being Famous Doesn't Make You Interesting

Some video game protagonists have earned legendary reputations, but are they all they’re cracked up to be? It’s easy to swallow whatever character we see and tell ourselves that they can do no wrong, but if you pull at the thread, you slowly unravel just how overrated some of the most beloved protagonists may actually be. Even well-loved franchises aren't immune to disappointing character development, and sometimes the supporting cast ends up being far more memorable than the person you're controlling. With that, it’s time to ruffle some feathers and dive into which 20 protagonists might not deserve so much praise.

1794859130b969c184d8b652f9d45516c21e6f78a1d5998bf5.jpgAlex de Koning on Unsplash

Advertisement

1. Master Chief

Master Chief might be one of gaming's most recognizable heroes, but let’s be honest: a lot of his popularity comes from the franchise. Throughout the original trilogy, he spends most of his time following orders and letting Cortana handle the more interesting conversations. Yes, later games explore his humanity, but his reputation as an exceptional character exceeds what we actually see of him.

1794859165bb97255590ddefa537edf3421bd3003b937fbb06.jpgErik Mclean on Unsplash

Advertisement

2. Nathan Drake

Nathan is handsome. Nathan has big muscles. Nathan is an all-around cool guy with plenty of charm. The thing is, his wisecracking personality gets exhausting when nearly every dangerous situation turns into another punchline. Not to mention, this guy really needs to grow up (just ask Elena). 

17948591804aedb9c743011b9c918fc58a5e389c9459d2687c.jpgRyan Quick from Greenbelt, MD, USA on Wikimedia

Advertisement

3. Kratos

The modern God of War games have done an impressive job developing Kratos, but his earlier appearances weren't exactly subtle. Across the original saga, he was really just an angry boy obsessed with revenge, and that rage overshadowed opportunities for a more complicated story. Even with his later growth as a father, it's only fair to question whether his reputation sometimes benefits from how much the games themselves have improved.

1794859192c2bf9b44754e75f9a409f24ac9053640ac966a25.jpgAleksandar Velickovic on Unsplash

Advertisement

4. Mario

No, we’re not just saying this because we like Luigi better. We just think it’s time to admit that Mario rarely demonstrates much personality beyond his enthusiasm and determination. There's nothing wrong with a straightforward hero, but his popularity doesn't automatically make him a compelling protagonist.

1794859204c7547e5b3d65d3aabbe0b4162c947083df159b67.jpgMax Harlynking on Unsplash

Advertisement

5. Aloy 

Aloy's smart as a whip and can kick serious butt, both of which make her an impressive heroine. However, her tendency to explain everything is…frustrating. She always comments on puzzles and obstacles before we even have an opportunity to work things out on our own. Her reluctance to accept help also creates conflicts that sometimes feel unnecessarily prolonged.

179485921908d46929b017b7f81dc76f4a81c7dcc9f10de46c.jpgPlayStation Taiwan on Wikimedia

Advertisement

6. Ezio Auditore

Ezio remains a favorite among Assassin's Creed fans, but nostalgia only takes us so far. Much of Assassin's Creed II follows a familiar revenge narrative, with Ezio pursuing the people responsible for destroying his family. He sees a little more development across three games, but it shouldn’t take that long to make something from nothing. 

1794859233e9d345ef57c0774b017391c822396b48f5c031f2.jpgInsulinde on Wikimedia

Advertisement

7. Geralt of Rivia 

Geralt has an enormous following, we know, but his deliberately restrained personality doesn’t appeal to everyone. Come on, just look at The Witcher 3—you have Bloody Baron, Yennefer, and Ciri, all of whom frequently provide the most emotionally engaging moments. We hate to say it, but Geralt’s a lot less fascinating than the complicated people around him.

179485925009fd7fc1d76b6bc9f3b7affe1fb72a6c2021387c.jpgDaniel Lee on Unsplash

Advertisement

8. Sonic the Hedgehog 

Sonic's a little guy with attitude, and that alone helped distinguish him from other gaming mascots. But those qualities haven't always translated into great characterization. Plenty of his games rely on his familiar jokes and unwavering optimism, even when the story tries to sneak in the more serious stuff. His personality is sure recognizable, but that alone can't compensate for inconsistent writing across the franchise.

179485926035eeb3cc624a9e525f3e6d44924a938743f1b1fb.jpgNik on Unsplash

Advertisement

9. Cloud Strife

Cloud's complicated identity and personal struggles give him more depth than the average vanilla protagonist, but his popularity can overshadow the contributions of other Final Fantasy VII characters. Tifa, Aerith, and Barret often demonstrate more immediately engaging personalities, so there’s a lot of competition. Not to mention, his companions are more enjoyable to spend time with.

17948592806ccebc101967a2b0d7152b7195e8d5130b17bcf3.jpgMichael Mol on Wikimedia

Advertisement

10. Sora 

Sora's cheerful determination gives Kingdom Hearts much of its appeal, but we have some bad news: his personality hasn't evolved as dramatically as the franchise's story. Even during Kingdom Hearts III, he regularly relies on the power of friendship while other characters grapple with the real world. His optimism is endearing, yes, but it can also make him seem surprisingly blah.

17948593041a8549f64ed49ef04925360ddc9f79bdf2df0e40.jpgLostplanetKD73 on Wikimedia

Advertisement

11. Lara Croft

We can’t deny that Lara Croft had the gaming world in a chokehold when we first laid eyes on her. The thing is, her characterization has varied far too much between different versions of Tomb Raider. The 2013 reboot presents her as an inexperienced survivor, yet the gameplay has her defeating enormous numbers of armed enemies. That disconnect doesn't ruin the adventure, but it makes her supposed transformation feel less convincing than the story intends.

1794859324a1d70992bd50119183f7a2291489bc14d86014db.jpgRyC - Behind The Lens from San Francisco, United States of America on Wikimedia

Advertisement

12. Gordon Freeman

Gordon’s silence is obviously there to immerse us in Half-Life, but it also means the supporting characters carry nearly every meaningful conversation. Alyx, for example, establishes an engaging personality while Gordon spends their encounters listening without offering much of a response. It's just tough to credit him with the emotional depth that other protagonists have.

17948593457df64579ee1eaf02cad57e6fcc2df1fe703104b1.jpgLong Zheng from Melbourne, Australia on Wikimedia

Advertisement

13. Marcus Fenix

Marcus certainly looks and sounds the part of a hardened soldier, but his gruff personality is rather predictable, no? Throughout the original Gears of War trilogy, Dom often provides the emotional vulnerability that Marcus rarely expresses, and that’s not something we missed. Much of his appeal depends on familiar military-action conventions.

179485937339232e2c06d600c4a2c8251c962e9dbba1925181.jpgSergey Galyonkin from Berlin, Germany on Wikimedia

Advertisement

14. Jason Brody

Jason Brody's transformation from frightened tourist into dangerous fighter is central to Far Cry 3, but the character isn't always convincing. He becomes way too comfortable participating in violence while his friends stay desperate to escape. Not to mention, with Vaas delivering some of the game's most memorable scenes, Jason’s constantly floundering to keep our attention.

1794859389084b26cb4ed63e93d18db1b70c71c3280fa55077.jpgSergey Galyonkin on Wikimedia

Advertisement

15. Deacon St. John

Deacon St. John has a tragic backstory and understandable reasons for being the way he is, but his constant irritation can make him difficult to appreciate. All that angry muttering and his constant arguments undermine scenes that could otherwise establish meaningful connections. Sure, his loyalty to Sarah and Boozer offers some warmth, but you really need to wade through an insufferable display before you see his sympathetic qualities.

179485943653d78d7fa63f3ff9e197f2cb7ccca43f925677e8.jpgFlorian Olivo on Unsplash

Advertisement

16. Aiden Pearce

Aiden’s personal tragedy gives him a reason to pursue revenge, but his demeanor doesn't always make that pursuit engaging. Throughout the original Watch Dogs, his interactions actually lack the humor and personality that could have distinguished him from other brooding heroes. Hacking Chicago is more interesting than the guy doing it. 

1794859453cf9198352614b031ec0f84afb3245c7384208931.jpgPikawil from Laval, Canada on Wikimedia

Advertisement

17. Cal Kestis

Cal Kestis’s personality just feels overshadowed by the larger Star Wars universe. Despite a few compelling experiences, his companions have more intriguing personal conflicts. Jedi: Survivor thankfully developed him further, but his journey still benefits from the established mythology surrounding him.

1794859472f487f0044d236284c9f12c3ef3be8132b8cba4f3.jpgVenti Views on Unsplash

Advertisement

18. Duke Nukem

You know the name, but is that enough to make Duke Nukem stand on his own? Call us crazy, but between the repetitive jokes and constant attempts at appearing cool, the whole schtick got old years ago. What once seemed rebellious now feels surprisingly dated.

17948594960d16e072f9cd836663e54129629811ac825c25d7.jpgRussell Bernice from Seattle, USA on Wikimedia

Advertisement

19. Trevor Philips

Hey, we all love sticking Trevor in a dress and robbing some guy blind, but let’s not forget that he’s only one of three protagonists—each with their own story. Let’s also not forget that he’s a violent lunatic who really shouldn’t be revered. Okay, yes, his darker moments offer commentary on the game's criminal world, but his antics eventually get a little old.

1794859512faa388c9c4f9a337e269169d794b9a9375b7343d.jpgSven Mandel on Wikimedia

Advertisement

20. Link

We know it sounds crazy, and we’re sorry, but Link’s enduring silence limits how much personality he really has. Characters around him aren’t afraid to wear their hearts on their sleeves, while this guy responds with minimal visible emotion. His understated nature might give us room to imagine ourselves as the hero, but that approach doesn't necessarily make him one of gaming's most interesting personalities.

17948595344072f31259422374fb58a9d701084979a790f1a4.jpgRyan Quintal on Unsplash

Advertisement